GuestLoop vs TouchStay for Vacation Rentals
Digital guidebooks: Guest experience vs Revenue optimization
Quick Verdict (TL;DR)
TouchStay is a digital guidebook platform focused on enhancing guest experience with beautiful, detailed property guides. GuestLoop includes digital guidebook functionality but focuses on the complete revenue cycle: email capture (90%+ rate), CRM with email marketing automation, and driving direct rebookings.
- ✓ Your #1 goal is reducing OTA fees and building direct bookings
- ✓ You want high email capture rates (90%+)
- ✓ You need email marketing automation built-in
- ✓ You want guest experience + revenue optimization
- ✓ You measure success by rebooking rates and ROI
- ✓ Your #1 goal is exceptional guest experience
- ✓ You want the most detailed guidebook features
- ✓ You'll handle email marketing separately
- ✓ You prioritize guidebook aesthetics over marketing ROI
- ✓ You measure success by guest satisfaction scores
Bottom line: TouchStay = guest experience. GuestLoop = guest experience + revenue recovery ($2,847 avg annually).
The Core Difference: Purpose & Philosophy
TouchStay's Purpose
Focus: Deliver an exceptional guest experience through beautiful, comprehensive digital guidebooks.
Philosophy: Happy guests leave great reviews, refer friends, and come back. The guidebook is the centerpiece of guest communication.
Success Metrics:
- • Guest satisfaction scores
- • Review ratings
- • Support ticket reduction
- • Guidebook engagement
GuestLoop's Purpose
Focus: Drive direct bookings and reduce OTA dependency through email capture, CRM, and marketing automation.
Philosophy: The guidebook is the gateway to guest emails. Use it to capture contacts, then nurture relationships over 6-12 months to drive direct rebookings.
Success Metrics:
- • Email capture rate (90%+)
- • Direct rebooking rate (12-15%)
- • OTA fees saved ($2,847 avg)
- • Campaign ROI (8-12x)
Analogy: Restaurant vs Loyalty Program
TouchStay is like a restaurant focused on delivering an amazing dining experience (beautiful menu, great service, memorable ambiance). GuestLoop is like that restaurant PLUS a loyalty program that captures customer emails, sends promotional offers, and brings diners back month after month. Both care about experience, but one also optimizes for revenue.
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
| Feature | GuestLoop | TouchStay |
|---|---|---|
| Digital Guidebook | ✅Yes (focused on email capture + info) | ✅Yes (detailed, feature-rich) |
| Email Capture | ✅Built-in, optimized (90%+ capture rate) | ✓Available but not primary focus |
| Email Marketing CRM | ✅Full CRM with 25+ STR templates | ❌Not included |
| Marketing Automation | ✅Built-in (welcome, review, rebooking campaigns) | ❌Not included |
| Rebooking Campaigns | ✅Automated with timing triggers | ❌Not included |
| Guest Segmentation | ✅Advanced (property, stays, engagement) | ✓Basic tagging |
| SMS Messaging | ✅Included (pay per message) | ✓Available |
| AI Blog Generator (Business) | ✅Auto-generate SEO local guides | ❌Not available |
| Market Intelligence (Business) | ✅AI competitive analysis | ❌Not available |
| UGC Digital Guestbook (Business) | ✅Instagram/TikTok integration | ❌Not available |
| Social Media Publishing (Business) | ✅Multi-platform auto-posting | ❌Not available |
| Interactive Maps (Business) | ✅Location recs with blog links | ✓Basic map features |
| Guidebook Customization | ✓Good (logos, colors, content) | ✅Excellent (highly customizable) |
| Guidebook Features | ✓Essential info (wifi, rules, recommendations) | ✅Extensive (interactive maps, videos, etc.) |
| ROI Tracking | ✅Revenue attribution, campaign ROI | ➖Not applicable (no marketing features) |
| Review Automation | ✅Automated review request campaigns | ⚠️Manual or requires integration |
| Multi-Property | ✅Unlimited (Pro plan) | ✅Yes, with tiered pricing |
| PMS Integration | ✅Major PMS platforms | ✅Major PMS platforms |
| QR Code Access | ✅Yes | ✅Yes |
| Mobile Optimization | ✅Yes | ✅Yes |
| Primary Goal | 💰Revenue optimization & direct bookings | ⭐Guest experience & satisfaction |
Legend: ✅ Excellent | ✓ Good | ⚠️ Limited | ❌ Not Available | ➖ Not Applicable
Pricing Comparison
GuestLoop Pricing
Full features, 20 SMS credits
Includes: Guidebook + CRM + Email Marketing
1-3 properties, 100 SMS/month
Includes: Guidebook + CRM + Email Marketing
4-10 properties, 300 SMS/month
+ AI Blog, Market Intel, UGC, Social Publishing, Maps
What You Get:
- • Digital guidebook
- • Email capture (90%+ rate)
- • Full CRM & email marketing
- • Campaign templates
- • Automation workflows
TouchStay Pricing
1 property
Guidebook only (no CRM)
Up to 5 properties
Guidebook only (no CRM)
Up to 25 properties
Guidebook only (no CRM)
What You Get:
- • Digital guidebook (advanced features)
- • Guest communication tools
- • Basic email collection
- ✗ No CRM
- ✗ No email marketing automation
Apples-to-Apples Comparison:
Host with 3 properties wanting guidebook + email marketing:
- • Growth: $29/month (1-3 properties)
- • Business: $79/month (4-10 properties)
- • Annual: 20% discount on all plans
- ✓ Built for independent hosts (1-10 properties)
- ✓ All include CRM & email marketing
- • TouchStay: $30/month
- • Mailchimp (150 contacts): $20/month
- • Combined monthly: $50
- • Combined annual: $600
- ⚠️ Requires manual integration
GuestLoop at $29/month ($348/year) vs TouchStay + Mailchimp ($600/year) - similar cost but fully integrated with better ROI tracking.
Which Should You Choose?
✅ Choose GuestLoop If:
Your Primary Goal is Revenue:
- →Reduce OTA fees and build direct booking channel
- →Drive repeat bookings through email campaigns
- →Measure success by rebooking rates and ROI
You Want All-in-One:
- →Don't want to integrate multiple tools
- →Need guidebook + CRM in one platform
- →Value simplicity and speed to results
✓ Choose TouchStay If:
Your Primary Goal is Experience:
- →Focus on guest satisfaction and reviews
- →Want the most feature-rich guidebook possible
- →Marketing and CRM are not immediate priorities
You'll Handle Marketing Separately:
- →Already have a CRM/email marketing solution
- →Comfortable integrating multiple tools
- →Just need a guidebook for now
💡 Can You Use Both?
Yes, some hosts use both: TouchStay for detailed property guides and GuestLoop for email capture and marketing automation. However:
Pros:
- • Get best-in-class guidebook features from TouchStay
- • Get revenue optimization from GuestLoop
Cons:
- • Higher combined cost ($59-109/month)
- • Overlap in guidebook functionality
- • Two platforms to manage
Most hosts find GuestLoop's guidebook sufficient for their needs and consolidate to save costs and complexity.
ROI & Results Comparison
The Revenue Question:
TouchStay improves guest experience, which indirectly helps with reviews and rebookings. However, it doesn't provide tools to proactively market to guests for direct bookings. GuestLoop focuses specifically on revenue recovery through email capture and marketing automation, with measurable ROI.
GuestLoop Typical Results
TouchStay Typical Value
The Bottom Line on ROI:
TouchStay is an operational expense that improves guest experience. GuestLoop is a revenue-generating investment with measurable ROI. If you're trying to reduce OTA dependency and build direct bookings, GuestLoop's email marketing capabilities make it the better choice for ROI.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I migrate from TouchStay to GuestLoop?
Yes. You can recreate your guidebook content in GuestLoop (which is straightforward) and start using the email marketing features immediately. Most hosts complete the migration in 1-2 hours per property.
Is GuestLoop's guidebook as good as TouchStay's?
GuestLoop's guidebook covers all essential information (wifi, house rules, local recommendations, check-in/out instructions) with good customization. TouchStay offers more advanced guidebook features (interactive maps, videos, detailed local guides). For most hosts, GuestLoop's guidebook is sufficient, especially when combined with the CRM value.
Why doesn't TouchStay include email marketing?
TouchStay focuses on being the best digital guidebook platform, not a marketing CRM. Their philosophy is to excel at guest experience, leaving email marketing to other specialized tools. GuestLoop takes a different approach by integrating both.
Can TouchStay capture emails like GuestLoop?
TouchStay can collect guest information, but it's not designed as an email capture and marketing platform. GuestLoop achieves 90%+ capture rates because the entire flow is optimized for email collection followed by marketing automation.
Which has better customer support?
Both offer good support. TouchStay focuses on guidebook setup and guest experience issues. GuestLoop focuses on email marketing strategy and direct booking optimization. Choose based on where you need more guidance.
Do most hosts use one or both?
Most hosts consolidate to one platform to save costs and complexity. Hosts prioritizing guest experience over revenue choose TouchStay. Hosts prioritizing direct bookings and OTA reduction choose GuestLoop.
Final Verdict
TouchStay = Best-in-class guest experience
GuestLoop = Guest experience + Revenue optimization
If your primary goal is reducing OTA fees and building direct bookings, GuestLoop delivers measurable ROI that TouchStay cannot match.
14-day free trial • No credit card required • Plans from $0-79/month properties
Want to learn more about vacation rental CRMs?